Well we know a few things. For one, there are only two mafia because there's only 6 of us left and if there were 3 we already would've lost. Second, we're in LYLO.
Based on Eric's awful play last night and leaving his vote on Kerzi when she's conftown I'm tempted to go after him. But I also know sometimes he just plays stupid and that makes me nervous to vote for him in LYLO. I have to think on it but for now:
Having said that...there is a chance that if the old lady is in play, that one of the remaining maf is actually (unknowingly) not maf. I think the more likely option is, however, between one of these two: Gillcup actually is the old lady, or Gillcup is Gillcup and there is no old lady.
KoN (S5) TLDR (S3), CIN & PAN (tournie)