2-2-2-12 cropper and 3-3-3-9 croppers with variations

Rtelling · Feb 13th 2018, 9:49pm

Templar Knight wrote:

I have always wanted to have a village with only cropfields (x18)
Heavy raiding and some ingenuity will bring in the resources.

Spawn them at a rate of about 10% of the 1st days registrations.

Imagine having about 2 of those in your account.

The warehouse will need a lot of time to get filled up haha

daz · Feb 13th 2018, 9:55pm

Templar Knight wrote:

I have always wanted to have a village with only cropfields (x18)
Heavy raiding and some ingenuity will bring in the resources.

Spawn them at a rate of about 10% of the 1st days registrations.

Imagine having about 2 of those in your account.

I think this is possibly the best thing I have ever seen Travian staff suggest. Why don't you forward your suggestion to the tech/dev teams at HQ :thumbsup:

They would likely listen to you more than any of us peasants down here

iRonik · Feb 13th 2018, 11:03pm

Rtelling wrote:

The warehouse will need a lot of time to get filled up haha

Rather unlikely, as you'd probably be golding there like a maniac. Upgrading res fields is practically useless in those anyway... That being said, @day50 you would probably be rocking lv17 fields and a 120k/h production, you probably know where this leads to.

Countless alarms and everything, otherwise crop spillage.

Templar Knight wrote:

I have always wanted to have a village with only cropfields (x18)

In the most optimal example it's like having a 15c, but only 20% more crop production.
In the case of an Egyptian however with a small diet artifact you'd be able to hold 840k/h worth of troops, which is quite an absurd amount to hold and NOT have negative crop.

That being said, if implemented I'd make it as a gray area exclusive, so people there would be able to hold more troops, since they're more endangered than those who have settles in Antarctica or Greenland.

Pumpkin Pie wrote:

This could easily be added on to 2-2-2-12 villages with 1-2-3-12, 1-3-2-12, 2-3-1-12, 2-1-3-12, 3-1-2-12, or 3-2-1-12 variations

The Idea of a 2-2-2-12 was brought up multiple times, but it never caught up because:

-A 15c is what it is, you need to import a lot of res and spend some gold on it if you want to develop it fast.
-A 9c being somewhat self-sustainable by having 3 res fields of each, does need some res import, but not so much and gold is basically not a must.
-A 12c would be the perfect middle between those theoretically, but yet 2 fields of each resource means you're not getting nearly enough of other res for it to be self-sustainable and you'd probably have to import a lot and spend some gold on it regardless. In which case you're better off with a 15c.

And regarding variations, it's just not worth with this few fields. You don't see variations of 9c already.

Mod Deadpool · Feb 14th 2018, 1:11am

daz wrote:

Templar Knight wrote:

I have always wanted to have a village with only cropfields (x18)
Heavy raiding and some ingenuity will bring in the resources.

Spawn them at a rate of about 10% of the 1st days registrations.

Imagine having about 2 of those in your account.

I think this is possibly the best thing I have ever seen Travian staff suggest. Why don't you forward your suggestion to the tech/dev teams at HQ They would likely listen to you more than any of us peasants down here

When it comes to the Dev, we are equals.

Every suggestion on the forum is compiled and forwarded to them weekly. So any good suggestions will definitely be forwarded to them.

daz · Feb 14th 2018, 3:50pm

Mod Deadpool wrote:

daz wrote:

Templar Knight wrote:

I have always wanted to have a village with only cropfields (x18)
Heavy raiding and some ingenuity will bring in the resources.

Spawn them at a rate of about 10% of the 1st days registrations.

Imagine having about 2 of those in your account.

I think this is possibly the best thing I have ever seen Travian staff suggest. Why don't you forward your suggestion to the tech/dev teams at HQ They would likely listen to you more than any of us peasants down here

When it comes to the Dev, we are equals. Every suggestion on the forum is compiled and forwarded to them weekly. So any good suggestions will definitely be forwarded to them.

So a 'CM' has no more influence than us guys at the bottom of the pecking order?

Templar Knight · Feb 14th 2018, 4:46pm

Hello daz

The developers are given any members suggestions as what you post here is reported.
I do gather information each week and put into a report we are asked to fill out about ideas and such from the forum.

So all ideas in a thread are always seen by Travian.

morgasshk_AU · Feb 15th 2018, 2:02am

18c yes. 12c no.

Right now, a 15c, the standard is to not build the res bonus buildings (except crop) as it does not add enough to be worthwhile. On a 12c, it will be tempting for peope to build these buildings, pain in the butt taking up those 3 extra slots.

And 18 c though? That would be nice :P

gorky_SK · Feb 15th 2018, 10:14am

morgasshk_AU wrote:

Right now, a 15c, the standard is to not build the res bonus buildings (except crop) as it does not add enough to be worthwhile

WHAT ?!

have you done the math for return of resources invested ? I bet you did not
even without sawmill / iron foundry / brickyard - those fields are definitely worth it and you should build them, altough on lower levels than crops obviously .
on average 2 levels lower W/C/I fields are about as effective as crops with 150% oases

Mercedes · Feb 15th 2018, 10:21am

Are you suggesting that you shouldn't build the factories for those fields? I read the previous post as it being the factories that aren't worth while in a 15c, not the fields, but that they might be worthwhile in a theoretical 12c.

iRonik · Feb 15th 2018, 10:23am

In a15c noting is as effective as crops with 150%.

gorky_SK · Feb 15th 2018, 11:18am

oh he was talking about those factories

well... they are always worth it - if you don´t need space for something else

in capitol obviously you do want more warehouses / granaries
but if you have c15 as non-cap, non-hammer village then why not build those buildings anyway ? they will pay for themselves

morgasshk_AU · Feb 16th 2018, 4:59am

And as Mercedes pointed out, yes, I meant the BONUS buildings, taking up a slot.

Ofc you build all fields up....

Mr.YP_AU · Feb 17th 2018, 4:13pm

18c is better cause its damn cropper.. but yeah limit it in gray zone + increase cats attack from natars so player must snipe or defend means they must defend some natar waves to make it fair and worth fighting for.. ofc player will hit them too but natars at second day hit will be great that will make them get more villa/defense first then go in for 18c

2-2-2-12 cropper and 3-3-3-9 croppers with variations

Templar Knight wrote:

Templar Knight wrote:

Rtelling wrote:

Templar Knight wrote:

Pumpkin Pie wrote:

daz wrote:

Templar Knight wrote:

Mod Deadpool wrote:

daz wrote:

Templar Knight wrote:

morgasshk_AU wrote:

Share

Users Online 1